God is alive, he cares and has an amazing purpose for your life. “Yeah right!” I hear you say. We live as cynical people in a cynical culture - just like in Malachi’s time. If you have ever heard a preacher quote from the book of Malachi I can almost guarantee it was in the context of trying to get money out of your pocket. “God will bless you if you tithe and curse you if you don’t” (yeah right...). No wonder we are cynical. But that’s not really what Malachi is about.
Background:
Malachi was a prophet in the period around 433BC. The Jews had returned from exile in Babylon and the temple had been rebuilt by 516BC. Their return had been due to some rather spectacular prophesy coming to pass and some incredible favour given to them through foreign rulers not usually in the habit of being generous! But 80 years later the people were in a state of stagnation. The excitement of return to the land and the miracles God had done in accomplishing this had been replaced by the mundane existence of day to day life. Prayer seemed somewhat pointless and there seemed to be little evidence to point to the presence or even existence of God apart from dry rituals from the past.
Into this culture of cynicism Malachi brings his sharp prophetic blade. He tries to expose the cancerous beliefs which have brought about the near-fatal slumber. He attempts to restore to them a vision of God’s love and gracious choosing of their nation. He speaks of the hope of the coming Messiah and the day of his justice and judgement. And he pinpoints the practices that are sure indicators of a corrupt heart condition. The blame is placed squarely on the shoulders of the religious leadership - the Levitical priests. Their attitudes and example have influenced the whole nation. He calls them firstly to repentance, in the confidence that the nation will follow, but with the realistic expectation that full cleansing will only be accomplished by the coming of the Lord himself to his temple.
Chapter 1 - God’s people forget who they are and who He is!
Malachi starts by re-affirming God’s love for Israel as a chosen nation. He describes an imaginary conversation between God and Israel to illustrate this:
“I have loved you.” says the Lord. But you say “How have you loved us?” (v2) In other words Israel’s response was “It doesn’t look like you love us - life is hard, people are ripping each other off (2:10), the wicked prosper and there is no justice (2:17), our economy is a mess because our crops are failing and we live in drought (3:10-11), our children are going astray (2:3), our marriages are falling apart (2:15), and you don’t seem to hear our prayers (2:13).”
So Malachi (speaking for God) explains what this love means by recounting the story of Jacob and Esau (1:2-5). These twin brothers are used in scripture to illustrate the doctrine of God’s sovereign choosing or election. God chooses individuals, tribes, cities and nations for his sovereign purpose. Being chosen creates both privilege and responsibility. (Election speaks of God’s call to service rather than - as commonly misunderstood - his call to eternal salvation - but that’s another story).
Another name for Jacob is Israel (Gen 32:28). Another name for Esau is Edom (Gen 25:30). Through Malachi God reminds the current descendants of Israel that he chose to set them apart as his chosen people - his representatives among the nations. His choice was based on his sovereign will even before the two sons had displayed their character or their works. God’s love set upon Israel had returned them to the land and ensured them of survival. In spite of their common displays of distinctly bad character and disobedient actions God had called them! Because he had called them and he would discipline, purify and correct them for the sake of his choosing (3:3). Edom on the other hand would reap the full consequences for their sin and face destruction. Israel would be disciplined but not consumed (3:6)! Good news so far...
After reminding them of the responsibility that comes with being God’s chosen people Malachi turns his sights on the leadership - the priests (1:6-7). He accuses them of despising the Lord. Malachi anticipates their horrified response “How have we despised your name?” He replies that when they bring inferior offerings to God they are despising, dishonouring and disrespecting Him. They were bringing the lame and sick animals to be offered to the Lord rather than the best and the unblemished of the herd and flock as commanded (Ex 12:5). Would they bring such offerings to an earthly governor (1:8)? God would rather the temple be closed than have these unacceptable sacrifices offered (1:10).
Verse 11 breaks in with a prophetic glimpse of the future where all the nations will offer acceptable pure sacrifices to the Lord. Part of the structure of Malachi is this switching between the “forth-telling” and the “fore-telling”. Forth-telling is the bringing forth of the hidden truth speaking into the current circumstances to bring change. The other and perhaps more familiar role of the prophet is to foretell the future. Malachi combines both for the purpose of providing incentive and hope that change is both very necessary and possible with the right perspective on the big picture.
Malachi then elaborates on the specific practices that are so offensive to him: the substitution of the best offerings for the sick, lame and stolen. They are even promising the best then substituting it for a blemished animal! Obviously they are not honouring God as the great King whose “name is feared among all the nations” (1:14). Their practices indicate hearts that have grown weary and lost a living faith.
Chapter 2 - The fallout of leadership failure
Malachi now delivers a direct warning to the priests - appealing to the law in Deuteronomy 28:16-20. They have not followed the Lord’s ways so they will and already are reaping a curse upon themselves (2:1-2). This has impacted their children and their celebrations before the Lord have become a farce (2:3). Malachi continues by recounting what was expected of the Levites. They were to revere God, give true instruction to the people, to walk with God in peace and righteousness and turn others from iniquity (2:4-6). They were preserve knowledge and give wise instruction as the spokes-people for the Lord (2:7).
The Levites were the descendants of Levi, son of Jacob. Moses and Aaron were of the tribe of Levi, and Aaron’s descendants were called firstly as priests of the Lord (Ex 29:9). Later after the passover when all the first-born males of Egypt were destroyed God set apart each first-born of Israel as consecrated to the Lord’s service, but he later spoke to Moses that he would take the Levites instead of every first-born to holy temple service (Numbers 3:12). They had no inheritance of land so they were to be supported by a tithe to be paid by the other people of Israel (Numbers 18:21,24).
This tithe was based on 10% of the food produced from the land (Lev 27:30) including the grain, new wine, oil, cattle, sheep and goats (Deut 14:22-23) This tithe seemed to have been required to be given to the Levites every third year (Duet 14:28). The other two years it (or at least the portion not put aside for the Levites) was to be eaten in the presence of the Lord as a joint celebration before the Lord (Deut 14:22-27). This feasting was to also include the Levite, the alien, the orphans and the widows who were unable to produce food for themselves (Deut 14:29).
So the sin of the Levites that Malachi highlights is that they have “corrupted the covenant of Levi” (2:8). They are showing partiality, offering and accepting inferior sacrifices and in all this providing a bad example to the people. They are unfaithful to God. So it is no wonder that although the Levites may “cover the altar of the Lord with tears” he “no longer regards the offering” (2:13). Their prayers hit the low ceiling and fall to the ground.
The fallout of unfaithfulness to God also has affected marriage relationships within Israel. Taking their covenant with God lightly the people have also taken their marriage covenants lightly. Malachi stresses God’s hatred of divorce and unfaithfulness and the impact that this has on raising up godly children (2:14-16). They have lost their awareness of God so their values have been distorted (or were their values distorted then they lost their awareness of God?) As an example of their distortion they say: “Everyone who does evil is good in the sight of the Lord, and he delights in them” (2:17). Perhaps this is just their cynicism speaking in that they also say “Where is the justice of God?” (2:17). In other words - when they failed to see God act in justice they became cynical and concluded that either God is evil, powerless, didn’t mind or didn’t notice. “God do something about evil? Yeah right!”
Chapter 3 - God’s promise of justice and call to repentance
In answer to the question “Where is the justice of God” Malachi responds in verse 1 by introducing “My messenger who will clear the way before me” speaking of John the Baptist (quoted in Matt 11:10 and mentioned again in 4:5). He also introduces “the messenger of the covenant, in whom you delight” - Christ himself. It seems that the “in whom you delight” is perhaps a little barbed. His coming will be anything but delightful should they fail to heed the word of Malachi. This messenger is coming to purify the sons of Levi and “refine them like gold and silver so that they may present to the Lord offerings in righteousness” (3:3).
Justice will begin to be restored in the nation once the leaders begin to practice righteousness. The Lord states that he will bring justice against sorcerers, adulterers, those who swear falsely, those who oppress the wage earner, the widow and the orphan, those who turn aside the alien and who do not fear him (3:5). If not for his covenant with Israel they would be consumed already, but because he is unchanging and will not break his promise he will purify the nation instead (3:6). He states that their turning aside has been “from the days of your fathers” (3:7). They were at least a generation away from those who had returned to the land and they had all but forgotten the Lord. It was time for a shake-up and Malachi delivered it.
So he speaks for them - “how shall we return?” (3:7). Now that their hearts were convicted they were ready to get back on track over specifics. In “tithes and offerings” (3:8). Malachi returns to the inferior offerings of chapter 1. As noted Malachi prophesied about 80 years after the return from exile. At the time of the return Nehemiah had brought the people back to their distinct identity as the people of God by restoring to them practices discarded when they had been in exile. They repented of their neglect of God’s laws and covenanted together to restore their practices. These practices are well summarised in Nehemiah 10:28-39. This included the resting of the land every 7 years, the release of debt, an annual contribution for the temple, the provision of the various sacrificial offerings, the supply of wood, and the bringing of the first-born and first-fruits as an offering to God, plus the tithe of the ground for the Levites (Neh 10:37-38,12:44). Essentially these were practices required for the smooth running of a just, sustainable nation where the poor were cared for and God was honoured.
By the time of Malachi these practices were again being neglected - shoddy offerings (1:13), neglect of the poor and unjust oppression of the powerless (3:5). They had neglected the Law of God and the covenant made just over a generation earlier. This had brought reproach on the nation and the curse upon their endeavours, just as they had acknowledged in Nehemiah’s time was the very reason for their state of exile (Neh 9:26-31). The blame is placed on “the whole nation” (3:9). The unbelieving, cynical “yeah right” attitude of the leaders had infected the people. God tells them that if they will return to him by returning to these practices then he will bring blessing “until it overflows” in place of curse, and he will “rebuke the devourer for you” (3:10-12).
Next God deals with their words. Their actions and their words both point to the sick, unfaithful and unbelieving heart of the nation. “Your words have been arrogant against me” (3:13). What words? “‘It is vain to serve God; and what profit is it that we have kept His charge, and that we have walked in mourning before the LORD of hosts? So now we call the arrogant blessed; not only are the doers of wickedness built up but they also test God and escape.’” (3:14-15) Perhaps these are the secret thoughts that they would never dare confess but are their true motivations? This theme is repeated through scripture - why do the wicked appear to prosper? (Jer 12:1, Ps 73:7 etc) Why should we be required to live in this seemingly rigid way while others are living it up however they like? There is no answer given in this part of Malachi - perhaps because they have already realised from chapter one that no matter how much they protest they are not like the other nations -they are the elect of God and they have both privilege and responsibility. What the nations appear to “get away with” in the short term is not the acceptable standard that God wants to display for the people that are called to be a “kingdom of priests and a holy nation” (Ex 19:6) and a “light to the nations” (Is 42:6).
So the people respond - those who “feared the LORD spoke to one another” (3:16). The passage says that God gave attention and heard it and now he records a “book of remembrance” noting down their names. He says that “they will be mine...on the day that I prepare my own possession” (3:17). He says that this is how we will be able to distinguish between the righteous and the wicked - the righteous are those that fear, serve and honour God. The wicked are those that are flippant, neglectful of their duty to God and unfaithful to his call (3:18).
Chapter 4- The wind-up
Malachi builds on the “on the day” theme of the previous chapter by again flipping into “foretelling” mode. We look through time to the day of the Lord when God’s name will finally be fully “feared among all the nations” (1:14). He uses the metaphor of burning introduced earlier in 3:2 to describe the effect of this day on the wicked and the righteous. In doing this he answers the question “why do the wicked prosper?” Ultimately they don’t. There are very real consequences for how we treat each other and whether we neglect God. In the blaze of the day of the Lord “all the arrogant and every evildoer will be chaff; and the day that is coming will set them ablaze” (4:1) They will be left with “neither root or branch” - perhaps indicating that they are completely without excuse on that day, or perhaps that their works are completely obliterated and all memory and influence of their evil is destroyed. But for the righteous the same fire that destroys the wicked appears as “the sun of righteousness will rise with healing in its wings” (or “rays” as some translations put it). To one the coming of the Lord is destruction - to others it is the final healing and a time of great joy where they will “go forth and skip about like calves from the stall” - free at last! All that is left of the wicked and their works are harmless ashes that melt away to nothing under the skipping feet (4:3).
He concludes by encouraging the people to “remember the law of Moses” (4:4) - well aware perhaps that this will not be the last time his people forget and slip into destructive patterns, and that law keeping will never be an ultimate solution to their unfaithfulness. So he adds a prophetic teaser: “Behold, I am going to send you Elijah the prophet before the coming of the great and terrible day of the LORD. He will restore the hearts of the fathers to their children and the hearts of the children to their fathers, so that I will not come and smite the land with a curse.” (4:5-6) We know from the New Testament that this is a prophesy regarding the preparatory ministry of John the Baptist (Matt 11:14 etc). The reference to the hearts of the children to their fathers could be referencing a faithfulness to God that transcends generations - something lacking in the present context - or perhaps a unity only possible through the work of the Spirit where the law is written on the hearts as in Jeremiah 31:33. This passage in Jeremiah explores similar themes around the day of the Lord, the joy at God’s justice and restored family relationships.
So the final hope left by Malachi is not so much that the nation will now be faithful to God forever, but an acknowledgement that keeping the Law is not the ultimate hope of the world. God’s intervention - veiled as it is at this point but revealed in Christ - is the hope of final justice. The people are left in no doubt however that they are loved, they are called, and their response is to be loving reverent obedience to their King.
And so?
I hope you see that Malachi isn’t about what preachers call “tithing” today. The tithe is a church tradition dating from the 6th century used to fund the Institutional Church - where Christianity was largely a cultural form rather than a lived-out reality. It was very loosely based on the tithe within Israel whereby a tenth of the produce of the ground (crops, animals, fruit) was used for the support of the Levites (who had not been allocated land) , and those who would be on social welfare today (widows, orphans and other poor). Only those who produced food from the land were required to tithe.
The early church didn’t carry on the practice but used whatever they could to help one another so that no-one was in lack. Leaders were self-supporting as much as possible and only received offerings where they were sure that there were no “strings attached”. They did not have purpose-built buildings or a priestly class so overheads were low. All the recorded church offerings taken up in the New Testament were for the support of poorer believers (including those taken up for Paul when he was imprisoned and would have starved unless they cared for him). The only references to the tithe were firstly from Jesus where he was rebuking the Pharisees for their minute attention to the details of the law over tithing of crops, and secondly the mention in Hebrews of Abraham’s tithe to Melchizedek. The point of the first is a rebuke to the Pharisees for their distorted values not encouragement for followers of Jesus to tithe. The point of Hebrews is the exaltation of Jesus as high priest of a better covenant which superseded the law - not an instruction for New Testament believers to tithe.
What is Malachi about then? We live on the other side of the prophesies about the coming of the promised one. We live in a weird split in history where justice has been won through the death and resurrection of Christ but not yet established in it’s fulness. Like the people in Malachi’s time it’s easy to have a “yeah right” attitude to God and either slip into dead empty tradition or perhaps more honest doubt as to the love, justice and even existence of God. We have to walk in faith looking over the horizon at something we can’t see yet, based on something from the past that has slipped over the other horizon. How do we know the love of God in these times? Actually by the fact that he doesn’t let us go. He doesn’t let his remnant disappear or true faith fade away. What feels like the painful rejection of God may just be him trying to get our attention so we will return to truth and justice. And to return to not just “belief” but to practice those things that reflect his care for people and for his creation.
Malachi is a lot like the New Testament book of James. James is very strong on practical faith and being genuine. He says “faith without works is dead”. He also speaks of the stricter judgement that falls upon leaders who teach as they set the example for the people to follow - good or bad. We can call ourselves Jews - or Christians - but labels don't count for much with God. The fruit of faith is shown by changed lives.
Cynicism is a highly contagious disease in our culture. It takes courage to reject the story that many people live by that says there is no hope and no justice so just "live it up" as best you can. Instead chose to say that God is alive, he does care and he does have an amazing purpose for my life. Yeah! Right!